Cut a seam through the codec enumeration, and say what a failed one actually does (#194)

probe() was 20 never-executed lines, the biggest single block on the report. It has been
looked at twice and left out twice, and both closes were right about what they closed:
#86 ruled it device-bound, and #133 re-checked that with ShadowMediaCodecList in hand and
still declined, because MediaCodecInfoBuilder has no setIsAlias and no setCanonicalName --
"so the alias skip and the canonical-name dedup, the two things the class's KDoc calls out
as easy to get wrong, are not reachable through it."

That objection is about the shadow. It does not apply to a function taking its own entry
type, which #133 did not evaluate. capabilitiesFrom(enumerate: () -> Sequence<CodecEntry>)
holds every rule; the edge keeps only the mapping from MediaCodecList onto CodecEntry.

The parameter is a Sequence rather than a List on purpose. runCatching has always wrapped
the *iteration*, so a MediaCodecInfo whose properties throw partway leaves the codecs
already read in place. A List parameter would move that throw outside the loop and turn a
partial answer into an empty one -- a behaviour change smuggled in as a refactor. There is
now a test for the partial case, and swapping the Sequence for an eager toList() reddens it.

The behaviour change this DOES make is one line of log, and it is the reason the seam was
worth cutting at all. The fallback said "Codec enumeration failed; assuming permissive" and
returned empty sets -- but "video/avc" in emptySet() is false, so canEncode and canDecode
answer no to everything and every job routes to FFmpeg. That is the restrictive answer, and
it is the right one: FFmpeg does whatever Media3 does, only slower. The code stays; the
message and the class KDoc now describe it.

Seven tests. One of them was wrong first and the mutation is what said so: the alias case
originally listed the alias *after* the codec it aliases and passed with the skip deleted,
because canonicalName is shared and the dedup catches the second entry either way. The two
rules overlap, so a fixture that does not separate them tests neither. Order separates
them -- an alias arriving first claims the canonical name in `seen` and gets its own types
credited, and the real codec is then dropped by the dedup. That is now the test, and it
also says what the rule is worth: with a Set accumulator, an alias declaring the same types
as its codec changes nothing, so the skip earns its place only when the two disagree.

Mutations, each run and restored, each reddening the test that owns it:

  drop !isSoftwareOnly from the encoder predicate     1 red
  remove the alias skip                               1 red  (0 before the fixture was fixed)
  remove the canonical-name dedup                     1 red
  remove the video/ prefix filter                     1 red
  apply the hardware predicate to decoders too        1 red
  make the failure fallback permissive                2 red
  eager toList() instead of the lazy Sequence         1 red

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

app/src/main/java/org/libremediaconverter/codec/AndroidDeviceCodecs.kt

@@ -21,6 +21,11 @@ import org.libremediaconverter.model.VideoCodec
  *   words, "cannot be tested for correctness". It is a hint, not a guarantee, which is
  *   why the router treats a failed hardware export as a signal to fall back rather
  *   than trusting this up front.
+ * - **An enumeration that fails answers no to everything**, which sends every job to
+ *   FFmpeg. Empty sets are not a permissive default: `canEncode` looks a MIME type up in
+ *   [hardwareEncodeMimes] and finds nothing there. That is the intended answer — FFmpeg
+ *   can do whatever Media3 can, only slower — but it is the opposite of what this class
+ *   said until #194, so it is written down rather than left to be re-derived.
  */
 class AndroidDeviceCodecs private constructor(
     private val hardwareEncodeMimes: Set<String>,
@@ -46,22 +51,62 @@ class AndroidDeviceCodecs private constructor(
 
         fun get(): AndroidDeviceCodecs = cached ?: synchronized(this) { cached ?: probe().also { cached = it } }
 
-        private fun probe(): AndroidDeviceCodecs {
+        /**
+         * One entry of the platform's codec list, reduced to what the rules below read.
+         *
+         * The five booleans and the type list are the whole of what [capabilitiesFrom] needs, and
+         * none of them can be set on a `MediaCodecInfo` from a test: Robolectric ships
+         * `MediaCodecInfoBuilder`, but it has no `setIsAlias` and no `setCanonicalName`, which is
+         * exactly the objection #133 raised against reaching this code through
+         * `ShadowMediaCodecList`. That objection is about the shadow. It does not apply to a
+         * function that takes its own entry type, which is why this exists.
+         */
+        internal data class CodecEntry(
+            val canonicalName: String,
+            val isAlias: Boolean,
+            val isEncoder: Boolean,
+            val isHardwareAccelerated: Boolean,
+            val isSoftwareOnly: Boolean,
+            val supportedTypes: List<String>,
+        )
+
+        /**
+         * The enumeration rules, over entries a caller chooses.
+         *
+         * [probe] is the only production caller and supplies the real codec list; a test supplies
+         * its own, which is the point — the two rules this class's KDoc calls out as easy to get
+         * wrong, the alias skip and the canonical-name dedup, are unreachable any other way.
+         *
+         * **`enumerate` returns a `Sequence`, deliberately.** The `runCatching` has to wrap the
+         * *iteration* rather than a list built before it, because a `MediaCodecInfo` whose
+         * properties throw does so partway through — and when that happens the codecs already read
+         * are kept. Taking a `List` here would move that throw outside the loop and silently turn a
+         * partial answer into an empty one. That behaviour predates this seam; a `List` parameter
+         * would have changed it as a side effect of a refactor.
+         *
+         * **An enumeration that fails answers restrictively, and that is deliberate.** The sets
+         * come back empty, and `"video/avc" in emptySet()` is `false`, so [canEncode] and
+         * [canDecode] both answer no and every job routes to FFmpeg. FFmpeg can do everything
+         * Media3 can, only slower, so refusing the hardware path is the safe reading of "we could
+         * not find out what this device supports". This used to log "assuming permissive", which
+         * described the opposite of what the code does.
+         */
+        internal fun capabilitiesFrom(enumerate: () -> Sequence<CodecEntry>): AndroidDeviceCodecs {
             val encoders = mutableSetOf<String>()
             val decoders = mutableSetOf<String>()
             val seen = mutableSetOf<String>()
 
             runCatching {
-                MediaCodecList(MediaCodecList.REGULAR_CODECS).codecInfos.forEach { info ->
+                enumerate().forEach { entry ->
                     // Aliases point at the same underlying codec; counting both would
                     // double-count capabilities.
-                    if (info.isAlias) return@forEach
-                    if (!seen.add(info.canonicalName)) return@forEach
+                    if (entry.isAlias) return@forEach
+                    if (!seen.add(entry.canonicalName)) return@forEach
 
-                    info.supportedTypes.forEach { mime ->
+                    entry.supportedTypes.forEach { mime ->
                         if (!mime.startsWith("video/")) return@forEach
-                        if (info.isEncoder) {
-                            if (info.isHardwareAccelerated && !info.isSoftwareOnly) {
+                        if (entry.isEncoder) {
+                            if (entry.isHardwareAccelerated && !entry.isSoftwareOnly) {
                                 encoders += mime
                             }
                         } else {
@@ -69,12 +114,32 @@ class AndroidDeviceCodecs private constructor(
                         }
                     }
                 }
-            }.onFailure { Log.w(TAG, "Codec enumeration failed; assuming permissive.", it) }
+            }.onFailure { Log.w(TAG, "Codec enumeration failed; routing everything to FFmpeg.", it) }
 
             Log.i(TAG, "Hardware video encoders: $encoders")
             return AndroidDeviceCodecs(encoders, decoders)
         }
 
+        /**
+         * The thin edge: the real codec list, mapped onto [CodecEntry] one at a time.
+         *
+         * Lazily, so a property that throws does it inside [capabilitiesFrom]'s `runCatching` and
+         * on the entry that caused it — see that function's note on why the parameter is a
+         * `Sequence`.
+         */
+        private fun probe(): AndroidDeviceCodecs = capabilitiesFrom {
+            MediaCodecList(MediaCodecList.REGULAR_CODECS).codecInfos.asSequence().map { info ->
+                CodecEntry(
+                    canonicalName = info.canonicalName,
+                    isAlias = info.isAlias,
+                    isEncoder = info.isEncoder,
+                    isHardwareAccelerated = info.isHardwareAccelerated,
+                    isSoftwareOnly = info.isSoftwareOnly,
+                    supportedTypes = info.supportedTypes.toList(),
+                )
+            }
+        }
+
         /**
          * `internal` rather than `private` so the cross-check test can ask what a [VideoCodec]
          * means here and compare it with what [NAME_TO_MIME] says the same codec's names mean.

app/src/test/java/org/libremediaconverter/codec/CodecEnumerationTest.kt

@@ -0,0 +1,201 @@
+package org.libremediaconverter.codec
+
+import org.junit.Assert.assertEquals
+import org.junit.Assert.assertFalse
+import org.junit.Assert.assertTrue
+import org.junit.Test
+import org.junit.runner.RunWith
+import org.libremediaconverter.model.VideoCodec
+import org.robolectric.RobolectricTestRunner
+
+/**
+ * The rules `AndroidDeviceCodecs.probe()` applies to the platform's codec list.
+ *
+ * ## Why this is not a third run of the #86/#133 spike
+ *
+ * #86 closed `probe()` as device-bound. #133 re-opened the question with
+ * `ShadowMediaCodecList` in hand and closed it again, for a reason that was right about what it
+ * was answering: `MediaCodecInfoBuilder` "has no `setIsAlias` and no `setCanonicalName`, so the
+ * alias skip and the canonical-name dedup — the two things the class's KDoc calls out as easy to
+ * get wrong — are not reachable through it."
+ *
+ * **That objection is about the shadow.** It does not apply to a function that takes its own entry
+ * type, which is what `capabilitiesFrom` now does. The half #133 named as unreachable is the half
+ * this file spends most of its cases on.
+ *
+ * ## What made the seam worth cutting, which is not coverage
+ *
+ * The `runCatching` fallback logged *"assuming permissive"* and returned empty sets — and empty
+ * sets are **restrictive**: `"video/avc" in emptySet()` is `false`, so `canEncode` and `canDecode`
+ * both answer no and every job routes to FFmpeg. The code was right and the message described the
+ * opposite of it. That is pinned below, so whichever reading a future change takes, it has to say
+ * so out loud.
+ *
+ * Robolectric only because `capabilitiesFrom` logs what it found; the rules themselves are pure.
+ */
+@RunWith(RobolectricTestRunner::class)
+class CodecEnumerationTest {
+
+    /**
+     * The alias skip, in the one arrangement where it is observable — and finding that arrangement
+     * is the whole of this test.
+     *
+     * A first attempt listed the alias *after* the codec it aliases and passed with the skip
+     * deleted, because `canonicalName` is shared and the dedup below catches the second entry
+     * either way. The two rules overlap, so a fixture that does not separate them tests neither.
+     *
+     * What separates them is **order**. `MediaCodecInfo.getCanonicalName()` on an alias returns the
+     * underlying codec's name, so an alias arriving first claims that name in `seen` and has its
+     * own `supportedTypes` credited — and then the real codec is dropped by the dedup. Without the
+     * alias skip the device is described by whichever entry the platform happened to list first.
+     *
+     * That also says what the rule is worth. With a `Set` accumulator, an alias declaring the same
+     * types as its codec changes nothing whichever order they arrive in; the skip earns its place
+     * only when the two disagree, which is exactly when believing the wrong one matters.
+     */
+    @Test
+    fun `an alias listed before the codec it aliases does not describe the device`() {
+        val codecs = capabilities(
+            entry("c2.qti.avc.encoder", encoder = true, types = listOf(HEVC), alias = true),
+            entry("c2.qti.avc.encoder", encoder = true, types = listOf(AVC)),
+        )
+
+        assertTrue("the real codec's types are the device's", codecs.canEncode(VideoCodec.H264))
+        assertFalse(
+            "an alias must not be credited with types the codec it aliases never claimed",
+            codecs.canEncode(VideoCodec.H265),
+        )
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    fun `two entries sharing a canonical name are read once`() {
+        val codecs = capabilities(
+            entry("c2.qti.avc.encoder", encoder = true, types = listOf(AVC)),
+            entry("c2.qti.avc.encoder", encoder = true, types = listOf(HEVC)),
+        )
+
+        assertEquals(setOf(AVC), codecs.hardwareEncoders())
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * Both halves of the hardware predicate, one arm at a time.
+     *
+     * A vendor may declare a codec hardware-accelerated *and* software-only; the class KDoc is
+     * explicit that the first flag "cannot be tested for correctness", so the second is what stops
+     * a mislabelled software encoder being treated as the fast path.
+     */
+    @Test
+    fun `an encoder counts as hardware only when it is accelerated and not software-only`() {
+        assertEquals(
+            setOf(AVC),
+            capabilities(entry("hw", encoder = true, accelerated = true, types = listOf(AVC))).hardwareEncoders(),
+        )
+        assertEquals(
+            emptySet<String>(),
+            capabilities(entry("sw", encoder = true, accelerated = false, types = listOf(AVC))).hardwareEncoders(),
+        )
+        assertEquals(
+            "a codec claiming both must not be trusted as hardware",
+            emptySet<String>(),
+            capabilities(
+                entry("both", encoder = true, accelerated = true, softwareOnly = true, types = listOf(AVC)),
+            ).hardwareEncoders(),
+        )
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * Decoders are collected regardless of the hardware flags, and that asymmetry is the design.
+     *
+     * `canDecode` asks whether the platform can read the input at all — a software decoder answers
+     * that as well as a hardware one. `canEncode` asks whether the *fast path* exists, which is a
+     * different question and why only encoders are filtered.
+     */
+    @Test
+    fun `a software decoder still counts as something the platform can read`() {
+        val codecs = capabilities(
+            entry(
+                "c2.android.avc.decoder",
+                encoder = false,
+                accelerated = false,
+                softwareOnly = true,
+                types = listOf(AVC),
+            ),
+        )
+
+        assertTrue(codecs.canDecode("h264"))
+    }
+
+    @Test
+    fun `audio types are ignored on both sides`() {
+        val codecs = capabilities(
+            entry("aac.encoder", encoder = true, accelerated = true, types = listOf("audio/mp4a-latm")),
+            entry("aac.decoder", encoder = false, types = listOf("audio/mp4a-latm")),
+        )
+
+        assertEquals(emptySet<String>(), codecs.hardwareEncoders())
+        // Not "the platform cannot decode AAC" -- `canDecode` is asked about *video* codec names,
+        // and an unknown name is answered permissively. The point is that nothing audio reached
+        // either set.
+        assertTrue("an unknown name stays permissive", codecs.canDecode("something-nobody-named"))
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * The failure fallback, pinned as the restrictive answer it actually is.
+     *
+     * #194 decided this rather than assuming it: the code stays, the message changes. If a later
+     * change wants the permissive reading its old log line described, this test is what makes that
+     * a decision instead of a drift.
+     */
+    @Test
+    fun `an enumeration that fails sends every job to FFmpeg`() {
+        val codecs = AndroidDeviceCodecs.capabilitiesFrom { error("MediaCodecList exploded") }
+
+        assertFalse("a failed enumeration must not claim a hardware encoder", codecs.canEncode(VideoCodec.H264))
+        assertFalse(codecs.canDecode("h264"))
+        assertEquals(emptySet<String>(), codecs.hardwareEncoders())
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * A list that throws partway keeps what it already read.
+     *
+     * This predates the seam — `runCatching` has always wrapped the iteration rather than a list
+     * built before it — and it is asserted here because the seam is where it could quietly have
+     * been lost. Taking a `List` instead of a `Sequence` would move the throw outside the loop and
+     * turn this partial answer into an empty one, with no test to notice.
+     */
+    @Test
+    fun `codecs read before a failing entry are kept`() {
+        val codecs = AndroidDeviceCodecs.capabilitiesFrom {
+            sequence {
+                yield(entry("good", encoder = true, accelerated = true, types = listOf(AVC)))
+                error("the sixth codec's properties threw")
+            }
+        }
+
+        assertEquals(setOf(AVC), codecs.hardwareEncoders())
+    }
+
+    private fun capabilities(vararg entries: AndroidDeviceCodecs.Companion.CodecEntry) =
+        AndroidDeviceCodecs.capabilitiesFrom { entries.asSequence() }
+
+    private fun entry(
+        canonicalName: String,
+        encoder: Boolean,
+        accelerated: Boolean = true,
+        softwareOnly: Boolean = false,
+        alias: Boolean = false,
+        types: List<String>,
+    ) = AndroidDeviceCodecs.Companion.CodecEntry(
+        canonicalName = canonicalName,
+        isAlias = alias,
+        isEncoder = encoder,
+        isHardwareAccelerated = accelerated,
+        isSoftwareOnly = softwareOnly,
+        supportedTypes = types,
+    )
+
+    private companion object {
+        const val AVC = "video/avc"
+        const val HEVC = "video/hevc"
+    }
+}