Commit Graph
2 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
JMR-devandClaude Opus 5 802997439d Let a join read the files the user actually picked (#238, #225)
Joining files picked through the system picker failed outright whenever
the strategy was stream copy -- the matched-files case the UI advertises
as "joined without re-encoding, no quality loss".

  [ffkitsaf @ ...] Protocol 'ffkitsaf' not on whitelist 'file,crypto,data'!
  Error opening input file .../joined_from_content.concat_list.txt

JoinScreen picks with OpenMultipleDocuments, so real inputs are always
content://. ConcatEngine maps each through getSafParameterForRead and
FFmpegConcatCommand writes the resulting ffkitsaf: paths into the concat
list file. The demuxer applies its own protocol whitelist, defaulting to
file,crypto,data, and -safe 0 does not touch it: that permits absolute
paths, this permits the scheme they carry. Two separate gates, and only
one was open.

Nothing caught it because the two halves of the bug never met. Only
STREAM_COPY feeds the demuxer a list file -- REENCODE passes each input
with its own -i, where the whitelist does not apply -- so joining over SAF
worked for mismatched clips. And every join test passed Uri.fromFile,
which takes ConcatEngine's uri.path arm instead of the bridge, so
matchingClipsAreJoinedByStreamCopy exercised stream copy with a file:
path and passed. The one broken combination was the one no test produced
and the only one a user can reach.

That is #225's gap: FFmpegKitConfig.getSafParameterForRead is on every
real conversion and join, and was on no passing test -- only on
UnopenableUriTest's failure side, which proves the error message rather
than the bridge. ContentUriInputTest now drives both the convert and join
paths from a real content:// URI.

It uses a plain ContentProvider, because the documents provider cannot be
reached. Measured three ways: a DOCUMENTS_PROVIDER without MANAGE_DOCUMENTS
is refused at install, instrumentation runs in the target app's process so
Instrumentation.getContext() still carries the app's uid and is denied, and
adoptShellPermissionIdentity(MANAGE_DOCUMENTS) is denied identically -- the
denial naming ACTION_OPEN_DOCUMENT as the only way in. The bridge needs no
documents provider: it opens a descriptor through the resolver, so any
readable content:// URI exercises it, and an ordinary provider may be
exported unprotected. The whole class stays headless. Recorded on #226,
which that also settles: its cheap half does not exist.

Verified on a local API 34 emulator: 66 tests, 0 failures, 3 skipped; and
removing the -protocol_whitelist pair reproduces the production failure
verbatim in the join test and nothing else. FFmpegConcatCommandTest pins
the flag on the JVM.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-06 01:42:03 -05:00
JMR-devandClaude Opus 5 b18f45def7 Give the system file picker something to pick
Nothing in either source set drives SAF as a picker. The only SAF coverage is the
publish side, in OutputPublisherPublishTest, against hand-written ContentProvider
fakes -- so the launcher wiring in ConverterScreen, the MIME filter it passes, and
the grant that comes back have never been executed by a test.

Driving the real picker needs three things this repo did not have.

UiAutomator, because DocumentsUI is another process. Compose's matchers stop at this
process's composition and Espresso's stop at its view hierarchy; neither can see or
tap a window belonging to another package.

It FLOATS, at "2.+", which is the same argument the catalog already makes for work
and lifecycle rather than a new one: androidx.test.uiautomator is inside
floatedGroupPrefixes, so the componentSelection guard makes "+" mean "newest
RELEASED", and that is load-bearing here -- this library publishes 2.4.0-alphas above
its stable, so without the guard the float would be a pin to a prerelease. Resolved
to 2.4.0 (released) on debugAndroidTestRuntimeClasspath, checked rather than assumed.
It is deliberately NOT pinned alongside ktlint/detekt/JaCoCo/Robolectric: those are
pinned because a new rule or a new runtime changes the verdict on files nobody
touched. UiAutomator has no verdict -- it taps what a selector names, and a selector
that stops matching is this repo's test to fix, in a diff that explains itself. The
"2." rather than a bare "+" is the one thing held back: a major is where the selector
API would be free to change under exactly that assumption.

A DocumentsProvider, because DocumentsUI does not browse a filesystem -- it lists what
providers offer it. Writing a file into Downloads would have worked and tested less:
the fixture root declares Root.COLUMN_MIME_TYPES, and DocumentsUI filters the drawer
by it, which is what gives the MIME filter a mutation with a shape rather than "one
file among the hundreds in Downloads was not listed". Its contents are also exactly
one file, where a shared directory accumulates whatever earlier runs left behind.

And the first AndroidManifest.xml this source set has ever had, to declare it -- a
ContentProvider is instantiated by the system and cannot be registered from test
code. In androidTest rather than src/debug so it is installed by the instrumentation
APK only, and never appears in a developer's own file picker.

Two things worth knowing before editing either file. XML comments cannot contain "--",
which the manifest's first draft failed the build on; and "*/" inside a KDoc closes
the comment, which the provider's did. Both are silent in review and loud in the
build.

No test yet, and no new test tag: TestTags.Converter.CHOOSE_FILE and FILE_CARD_NAME
already name both ends of the round trip.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-24 20:15:33 -05:00