Guard the whole Media3 export instead of only its two ends

transcode() posts its work to a HandlerThread, and everything on that
thread has no caller to throw back to: an escaping exception reaches the
thread's uncaught handler and takes the process down, while the
continuation is never resumed. Both halves of that are bad, and the
second is arguably worse — a worker left suspended forever holds a
foreground service.

The guarding was two narrow runCatching blocks, one around
buildTransformer and one around transformer.start, with the two Media3
builders sitting unguarded between them. That gap was not theoretical.
EditedMediaItem.Builder rejects a composition with both tracks removed,
which is exactly what a plan of (Drop, Drop) asks for, and it does so
with a plain IllegalStateException from the constructor.

Validation now refuses the spec that produces such a plan, so neither
the picker nor ConversionWorker will start one. Routing is a separate
question and still answers Media3 for it — a dropped track makes nothing
un-hardware-able — so a request that skips validation still arrives
here: a job queued before the settings changed, or one made through
ConversionWorker.request directly. CopyPlanner's own KDoc already names
that path as the reason it re-checks what validation has checked; this
is the same belt for the same braces.

One guard around the whole body costs nothing on success and turns any
such refusal into a failed job with a reason attached. The export body
moves into startExport, whose contract is the thing that makes one guard
enough: returning normally means the export is running and the listener
owns the continuation, throwing means it never started and the caller
does. Cancellation is still registered before start.

Covered twice on purpose. Robolectric runs the real HandlerThread and
the real Media3 builders, so the JVM test exercises the whole sequence
and can be run anywhere; the instrumented one repeats it against the
real framework. Neither asserts only that the failure is an
IllegalStateException, because withTimeout raises
TimeoutCancellationException and java.util.concurrent.CancellationException
extends IllegalStateException — so that assertion alone calls an
unresumed continuation a pass. Both were written that way first, and
reverting the guard is what exposed it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-25 20:57:41 -05:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5
parent 9c809d4e16
commit 238142d9cc
4 changed files with 263 additions and 33 deletions
@@ -68,42 +68,64 @@ class Media3Engine(private val context: Context) : HardwareTranscoder {
): Unit = suspendCancellableCoroutine { cont ->
val plan = CopyPlanner.plan(request.spec, request.probe)
handler.post {
val transformer = runCatching { buildTransformer(plan, cont) }
.getOrElse {
cont.resumeWithException(it)
return@post
}
// Dropping the tracks the target does not have is what stops an audio-only export
// from carrying a re-encoded video track. Without setRemoveVideo, asking for M4A
// produced an HEVC stream in a file named .m4a.
val item = EditedMediaItem.Builder(MediaItem.fromUri(input))
.setRemoveVideo(plan.video == VideoPlan.Drop)
.setRemoveAudio(plan.audio == AudioPlan.Drop)
.build()
// A Composition is the only way to ask for transmuxing; the plain
// start(EditedMediaItem, path) overload always re-encodes. This is the remux path.
val composition = Composition.Builder(EditedMediaItemSequence.Builder(item).build())
.setTransmuxVideo(plan.video == VideoPlan.Copy)
.setTransmuxAudio(plan.audio == AudioPlan.Copy)
.build()
cont.invokeOnCancellation {
// cancel() has the same single-thread requirement as start().
handler.post { runCatching { transformer.cancel() } }
}
runCatching { transformer.start(composition, output.absolutePath) }
.onFailure {
cont.resumeWithException(it)
return@post
}
pollProgress(transformer, cont, onProgress)
// One guard around the whole body, deliberately.
//
// This used to be two narrow ones — around `buildTransformer` and around
// `transformer.start` — with the two Media3 builders sitting unguarded between them.
// On this thread that is not a small gap: nothing here has a caller to throw back to,
// so an escaping exception reaches the HandlerThread's uncaught handler and takes the
// process down, while [cont] is never resumed either way. `EditedMediaItem.Builder`
// does exactly that for a plan that drops both tracks
// ("Audio and video cannot both be removed"), which a queued job can still carry.
// Widening the guard costs nothing on success and turns every such refusal into a
// failed job with a reason.
runCatching { startExport(input, output, plan, cont, onProgress) }
.onFailure { if (cont.isActive) cont.resumeWithException(it) }
}
}
/**
* Builds the export and hands it to Transformer. Runs on the HandlerThread; may throw.
*
* Everything Transformer's single-thread contract covers lives here, so that the caller has
* exactly one place to catch. Returning normally means the export is running and [cont] belongs
* to the listener; throwing means it never started and the caller owns resuming.
*/
private fun startExport(
input: Uri,
output: File,
plan: ConversionPlan,
cont: CancellableContinuation<Unit>,
onProgress: (Int) -> Unit,
) {
val transformer = buildTransformer(plan, cont)
// Dropping the tracks the target does not have is what stops an audio-only export
// from carrying a re-encoded video track. Without setRemoveVideo, asking for M4A
// produced an HEVC stream in a file named .m4a.
val item = EditedMediaItem.Builder(MediaItem.fromUri(input))
.setRemoveVideo(plan.video == VideoPlan.Drop)
.setRemoveAudio(plan.audio == AudioPlan.Drop)
.build()
// A Composition is the only way to ask for transmuxing; the plain
// start(EditedMediaItem, path) overload always re-encodes. This is the remux path.
val composition = Composition.Builder(EditedMediaItemSequence.Builder(item).build())
.setTransmuxVideo(plan.video == VideoPlan.Copy)
.setTransmuxAudio(plan.audio == AudioPlan.Copy)
.build()
// Registered before start(), so a cancellation racing the export always finds a
// transformer to cancel.
cont.invokeOnCancellation {
// cancel() has the same single-thread requirement as start().
handler.post { runCatching { transformer.cancel() } }
}
transformer.start(composition, output.absolutePath)
pollProgress(transformer, cont, onProgress)
}
/**
* @throws IllegalArgumentException if [plan] names a container Media3 cannot mux. That is a
* routing bug rather than a runtime condition — [org.libremediaconverter.model.ConversionRouter]